Clinical Trials
Hybrid Minimally Invasive vs Open Pancreaticoduodenectomy
Krishna et alSurgical endoscopy

Adoption of minimally invasive pancreaticoduodenectomy has historically been constrained by technical complexity, steep learning curves, and challenges surrounding safe biliary and pancreatic reconstructions. A single-center pilot randomized controlled trial evaluated a novel hybrid approach incorporating mini-laparotomy reconstruction, randomizing 36 patients equally to robotic-assisted Whipple (RAW), laparoscopic-assisted Whipple (LAW), or conventional open Whipple (OWL) procedures.
The study demonstrated that hybrid minimally invasive approaches confer distinct intraoperative and early postoperative recovery benefits. Median estimated blood loss was significantly reduced in the RAW cohort (200 mL) and LAW cohort (375 mL) relative to the OWL group (500 mL; p = 0.013). Furthermore, postoperative pain scores were significantly lower in both minimally invasive cohorts, with the most pronounced pain reductions achieved in patients undergoing robotic-assisted resection. Operative duration remained statistically comparable across all three arms, averaging 179.2 ± 27.8 minutes for RAW, 182.5 ± 32.5 minutes for LAW, and 165.0 ± 35.0 minutes for OWL (p = 0.267). Median hospital length of stay did not differ significantly between arms, at 7 days for RAW, 6 days for LAW, and 8 days for OWL (p = 0.228).
Postoperative complication profiles were assessed across all groups. Clinically relevant postoperative pancreatic fistula (CR-POPF) occurred in 3 of 12 patients in the RAW cohort, 1 of 12 in the LAW cohort, and 0 of 12 in the OWL cohort (p = 0.294). Bile leaks were recorded in 2 of 12 patients in the RAW group, 2 of 12 in the LAW group, and 1 of 12 in the OWL group (p = 1.000). The investigators concluded that hybrid robotic and laparoscopic pancreaticoduodenectomy using mini-laparotomy reconstruction is technically feasible, supporting the rationale for adequately powered multicenter randomized trials to validate safety, oncologic outcomes, and potential applicability in resource-constrained surgical settings.
Key Takeaways
- Robotic-assisted and laparoscopic-assisted hybrid pancreaticoduodenectomy significantly reduced median estimated blood loss (200 mL and 375 mL, respectively) compared to the traditional open approach (500 mL; p = 0.013).
- Postoperative pain scores were significantly lower in both minimally invasive groups compared with open resection, with the lowest pain levels observed in the robotic-assisted arm.
- Incidence of clinically relevant postoperative pancreatic fistula (3/12 in RAW, 1/12 in LAW, 0/12 in OWL; p = 0.294) and bile leakage (2/12 in RAW, 2/12 in LAW, 1/12 in OWL; p = 1.000) did not demonstrate statistically significant differences among cohorts.
Read the original sourceSurgical endoscopy
