Skip to content
    Guidelines & Consensus

    Suboptimal Concordance with Surveillance Colonoscopy Guidelines

    Foo et alAust Health Rev

    A retrospective clinical audit conducted across six public hospitals (three metropolitan and three rural) in Victoria, Australia, evaluated the concordance between endoscopist-recommended surveillance colonoscopy intervals and the 2018 Australian Cancer Council surveillance guidelines. Auditing covered colonoscopies performed between and , analyzing endoscopist recommendations against official guidelines using hospital reports, histopathology, and medical records. Of 465 consecutive cases audited, 248 involved recommendations for future surveillance and contained complete data. Overall, endoscopists recommended guideline-concordant return intervals in only 25.4% (63/248) of cases. Of the discordant recommendations, 74.6% (n = 138) were for intervals earlier than recommended by guidelines, 20.5% (n = 38) were not clinically indicated, and 4.9% (n = 9) advised intervals longer than recommended. When excluding cases where surveillance was not indicated, concordance varied considerably across guideline-recommended interval categories: 66.7% (8/12) for intervals ≤12 months, 58.3% (42/72) for 5-year intervals, 31.0% (13/42) for 3-year intervals, and 0.0% (0/84) for 10-year intervals. The study highlights a substantial pattern of premature surveillance recommendations, pointing to low guideline uptake several years post-publication and emphasizing the need for tailored implementation strategies to optimize resource utilization and clinical care.

    Key Takeaways

    • In a clinical audit of 248 post-colonoscopy surveillance recommendations across six Victorian public hospitals, endoscopists achieved guideline-concordant recall intervals in only 25.4% (63/248) of cases.
    • Among discordant surveillance recommendations, 74.6% (n = 138) recommended early repeat procedures, 20.5% (n = 38) were not clinically indicated, and 4.9% (n = 9) recommended delayed surveillance.
    • Adherence to the 2018 Australian Cancer Council guidelines varied by interval category, dropping from 66.7% (8/12) for ≤12-month intervals and 58.3% (42/72) for 5-year intervals to 31.0% (13/42) for 3-year intervals and 0.0% (0/84) for 10-year intervals.